Insights
Business Taxes

A client asks, "Can I write this off?" Section 162 answers the first half. Five more limits decide whether the deduction reaches the client's return this year.

Section 162: Deductible Is Not the Same as Currently Usable

Ordinary and necessary is the first test, not the last. Section 162(a) allows a deduction for the ordinary and necessary expenses of carrying on a trade or business. "Ordinary" means a cost that is common and accepted in that line of work. "Necessary" means appropriate and helpful, not indispensable. The Supreme Court drew that line in Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. 111 (1933), and Deputy v. du Pont, 308 U.S. 488 (1940).

Several provisions can override a cost that would otherwise meet that test. Personal, living, and family expenses are not deductible (Section 262). Capital expenditures, including costs required to be capitalized under Sections 263 and 263A, are recovered, if at all, under other provisions. Section 274 limits or disallows entertainment, meals, travel, and similar items, and it imposes substantiation rules that an estimate will not satisfy. As we discussed in our briefing on the Cohan rule and business expense records, contemporaneous records still matter. Section 280E is a clear example of a deduction the Code takes back: it disallows deductions and credits for a trade or business trafficking in Schedule I or II controlled substances, even when the expenses would otherwise be ordinary and necessary. The Department of Justice's April 2026 Final Order placed marijuana contained in FDA-approved products, and marijuana subject to a qualifying state medical marijuana license, in Schedule III. Adult-use marijuana, bulk marijuana, and unlicensed product remain in Schedule I. Treasury and the IRS have announced that they plan to issue guidance on the tax consequences, including a transition rule under which, for purposes of Section 280E, rescheduling would generally first apply for a business's full taxable year that includes the effective date of the Final Order, for the business's activities that do not involve Schedule I or II controlled substances as a result of the Final Order. That guidance has been announced. As of this writing, Treasury and the IRS have not issued a Notice, Revenue Procedure, Revenue Ruling, or regulation implementing it. Businesses licensed for both medical and adult-use sales still cannot deduct the costs of selling recreational marijuana, so they need an allocation between the two activities. California Revenue and Taxation Code section 17209 has, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2020, allowed deductions for licensed commercial cannabis activity on the California Individual return, so that return already differs from the federal result. The current statute applies to taxable years beginning before January 1, 2030. A rescheduling hearing on adult-use marijuana was held from June 29 through July 15, 2026. As of this writing, there is no final rule on adult-use rescheduling.

For S corporation owners, reasonable compensation is also a Section 162 wage question, and it directly controls the payroll tax outcome. If the compensation is too low, or if the corporation is not respected as the earner of the income, employment or self-employment tax can follow. We covered that risk in our briefing on Fleischer v. Commissioner and S corporation income. That wage question also sets up the self-employment tax discussion in Section 1402, later in this briefing.

The Loss Limitation Order

The usual list of Code sections is right. The order in which the limits apply is where many returns go wrong. Section 469 is not the first limit a loss has to clear, and it is not the second. Before the at-risk rules in Section 465 apply, the loss has to clear basis. Most practitioners skip basis entirely, or they treat a partner's share of debt and an S corporation shareholder's debt basis as if they worked the same way. They do not, and that is where many return errors start.

At the owner level, the order is:

  1. Basis, under Section 704(d) for partners or Section 1366(d) for S corporation shareholders.
  2. The business interest limitation under Section 163(j).
  3. The at-risk rules under Section 465.
  4. The passive activity rules under Section 469.
  5. The excess business loss rule under Section 461(l), for noncorporate taxpayers.
  6. Any remaining excess is treated as a net operating loss under Section 172.
Sequence diagram of the owner-level loss limitation order: basis under sections 704(d) or 1366(d), then section 163(j) business interest, then section 465 at-risk, then section 469 passive activity, then section 461(l) excess business loss, then section 172 net operating loss, with a carryforward shown at each step.

Temporary Treasury Regulation section 1.469-2T(d)(6) coordinates Section 469 with the limits that apply before it. An item disallowed under Section 704(d), 1366(d), or 465 is not a passive activity deduction for the year. The regulation is the usual authority for the order of those limits: the basis limitations, then the at-risk rules, then the passive activity loss rules. Section 461(l)(6) then provides that the excess business loss rule is applied after Section 469. A loss disallowed under Section 461(l) is treated as a net operating loss carryover under Section 172(b) for later years. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act made Section 461(l) permanent for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2026. The limitation already applies in 2026. For taxable years beginning in 2026, the threshold is $256,000, or $512,000 for a joint return (Revenue Procedure 2025-32). Net operating losses arising after 2017 offset only 80 percent of taxable income (Section 172(a)(2)), so the last step is a limit of its own. Section 163(j) is not in the Section 469 or Section 461(l) provisions. Treasury Regulation section 1.163(j)-3 and the December 2025 instructions to Form 8990 place it after the basis limitation and before the at-risk, passive activity, and excess business loss rules.

Partnerships and S corporations also apply Section 163(j) at the entity level, which can reduce the interest deduction before items reach the owner. Excess business interest expense allocated to a partner reduces the partner's outside basis even though it is not yet deductible. If Section 704(d) suspends that allocation, it becomes negative Section 163(j) expense under Treasury Regulation section 1.163(j)-6(h) and does not reduce basis until the suspension is released. Applying Section 163(j) after the basis limitation does not conflict with that basis reduction. Disallowed business interest of an S corporation stays at the entity and is carried forward there, rather than being allocated out as excess business interest.

For many clients in the $400,000 to $30 million range, the Section 163(j) step does not end up limiting the deduction. A taxpayer that meets the gross receipts test of Section 448(c) is generally exempt, unless the taxpayer is a tax shelter. For taxable years beginning in 2026, that gross receipts threshold is $32 million (Revenue Procedure 2025-32). A syndicate is a tax shelter and loses the exemption. An entity is a syndicate if more than 35 percent of its losses are allocated to limited partners or limited entrepreneurs (Section 1256(e)(3)(B)). That is common for real estate LLCs with passive members in their loss years. A real property trade or business may also elect out of Section 163(j) under Section 163(j)(7)(B). That election requires the business to use the alternative depreciation system for its nonresidential real property, residential rental property, and qualified improvement property.

A partner's basis generally includes a share of partnership liabilities under Section 752. An S corporation shareholder's basis does not increase for the entity's own loans from a bank or other third party. Only amounts the shareholder has actually loaned to the corporation create debt basis under Section 1366(d). Mixing those two rules is the most common way a K-1 loss is deducted too soon, or not deducted when it should be.

A loss stopped at an earlier layer never reaches the later ones. Each layer has its own carryforward, as the diagram shows. The labels are not the same: basis and at-risk produce suspended losses, Section 163(j) produces disallowed business interest, Section 469 produces a suspended passive loss, and Section 461(l) converts the excess into a net operating loss carryover.

Section 465: The Step Most Preparers Skip

Section 465 limits the deductible loss from an activity to the amount the taxpayer has at risk in that activity. In general, a taxpayer is at risk for money and the adjusted basis of property contributed, and for amounts borrowed for which the taxpayer is personally liable or has pledged property other than property used in the activity.

Nonrecourse debt usually does not increase the at-risk amount. The important real estate exception is qualified nonrecourse financing under Section 465(b)(6). If the statutory conditions are met, financing secured by real property used in the activity of holding real property can be treated as at risk even though the borrower is not personally liable. That is one reason a real estate partnership and an equipment or operating business can produce different results even when the K-1 shows similar liabilities.

Guarantees and LLC member debt are where basis and at-risk amounts often diverge. A partner may be allocated a share of partnership or LLC liabilities under Section 752, which increases basis, without being at risk under Section 465. Two common patterns illustrate the gap. First, nonrecourse debt that is not qualified nonrecourse financing is allocated under Treasury Regulation section 1.752-3, so it increases basis but not the at-risk amount. Second, a member guarantee can make the debt recourse to that member for Section 752 purposes. Whether it also increases the at-risk amount depends on whether the member is the payor of last resort, with no remaining reimbursement right. Proposed Treasury Regulation section 1.465-6(d) would not increase the at-risk amount on a guarantee until the taxpayer has paid the debt and has no remaining legal rights against the primary obligor. Amounts protected against loss by a stop-loss agreement or a similar arrangement are not at risk (Section 465(b)(4)). Amounts borrowed from a person who has an interest in the activity other than as a creditor, or from certain related persons, may also be excluded (Section 465(b)(3)). The return that deducts a loss because "the K-1 shows enough basis" has not finished the analysis.

Section 465(e) can also turn a previously allowed loss back into income. If the amount at risk is below zero at the close of the year, the taxpayer includes income equal to that shortfall. Under Section 465(e)(2), that recapture is limited to the losses previously allowed for the activity, minus amounts already recaptured. Cash distributions are a common trigger. So are changes that remove amounts from at-risk, including a shift from recourse to nonrecourse debt and the use of activity assets to repay certain debts. Not every debt paydown produces recapture. The test is whether the at-risk amount is negative at year end, and whether there are prior allowed losses to recapture. The recaptured amount is treated as a deduction allocable to the activity in the following year (Section 465(e)(1)(B)).

Section 469: Practical Traps for Operators Earning $400,000 to $30 Million

Section 469 generally allows passive activity losses only against passive activity income. For operators in the $400,000 to $30 million range, the traps are usually in the facts: hours, rental characterization, self-rental, grouping, and the timing of a disposition, not in the general rule itself.

Material participation is tested under the seven tests in Temporary Treasury Regulation section 1.469-5T(a). The ones that come up most often are the 500-hour test, the substantially-all test, the 100-hour test when no one else participates more, and the significant-participation test (more than 100 hours in each of several activities, totaling more than 500 hours). Those tests are only as good as the records behind them. Contemporaneous hour logs, kept as the work is done, are the evidence that holds up. A reconstruction prepared at filing time is weaker, for the same reason contemporaneous records matter under Section 274.

Rental activities are treated as passive even if the owner participates, unless an exception applies. Real estate professional status under Section 469(c)(7) is one of those exceptions, and it is often confused with a different rule for short-term rentals. To qualify as a real estate professional, one spouse must individually satisfy two hour tests: more than half of the personal services the taxpayer performs in trades or businesses during the year must be in real property trades or businesses in which the taxpayer materially participates, and those services must exceed 750 hours. Qualifying is not the end of the analysis. The taxpayer still has to materially participate in each rental activity, unless a valid election is in place to aggregate rental real estate under Treasury Regulation section 1.469-9.

The short-term rental rule is separate. If the average period of customer use is seven days or less, the activity is not a rental activity under Temporary Treasury Regulation section 1.469-1T(e)(3)(ii). Nonpassive treatment then depends on material participation, not on real estate professional status. A client who averages five-night stays can fail the real estate professional tests and still have a nonpassive activity if the hours satisfy one of the seven material participation tests. The reverse is also true: real estate professional status does not, by itself, make a short-term rental nonpassive if the taxpayer does not materially participate.

Self-rental is another place the facts cut only one way. Under Treasury Regulation section 1.469-2(f)(6), net income from renting property to a trade or business in which the taxpayer materially participates is recharacterized as nonpassive. A net loss from the same rental stays passive. For a client who owns a building and rents it to an operating company, that means rental profit cannot be sheltered by other passive losses, while a rental loss cannot offset the operating income. The grouping rules, discussed below, can change that result in some fact patterns, but only if the grouping itself is valid and properly disclosed.

Grouping under Treasury Regulation section 1.469-4 allows taxpayers to treat activities that form an appropriate economic unit as a single activity, which can change whether an hours test is met. Groupings are generally consistent from year to year. Revenue Procedure 2010-13 requires a written statement with the original return when activities are first grouped, when a new activity is added, or when a regrouping is required. If a taxpayer fails to make a required disclosure, each trade or business or rental activity is treated as a separate activity. In practical terms, an undisclosed grouping that was required to be reported is treated as no grouping. Relief can be available if the taxpayer discovers the failure first, has filed consistently with the claimed grouping, and makes the disclosure. Groupings that were already in place before the revenue procedure's effective date did not have to be disclosed until they were changed. In stacked or fund structures, grouping and participation are tested with care at each level. Our briefing on tiered partnerships and the passive loss rules covers those points in more detail.

Suspended passive losses are not gone. They carry forward and may be used against later passive income, or when the taxpayer disposes of the entire interest in the activity in a fully taxable transaction to an unrelated person (Section 469(g)). A sale to a related person does not produce that release. Exit planning is where suspended losses often produce their value, but only if the disposition is structured to meet the statute. Our briefing on selling a real estate partnership interest walks through how a disposition can release suspended losses, and why the gain may be taxed in more than one way.

Section 1402: The "Limited Partner" Answer as of November 2026

Section 1402(a)(13) excludes a limited partner's distributive share from net earnings from self-employment, other than guaranteed payments for services. The Code does not define "limited partner." For years, many partnerships treated a state-law limited partner label, or limited liability alone, as enough. That is no longer a safe reading in either circuit that has ruled. The partner also has to stay out of management.

The Tax Court established a functional test in Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner, 161 T.C. 310 (2023). A partner who is limited in name only, and who is not in substance a passive investor, does not qualify for the exception. In a later opinion on the merits, T.C. Memo. 2025-52, the court applied that test and held that Soroban's principals, who managed the firm full time, were not limited partners for this purpose.

The Fifth Circuit's path is easy to misstate because the caption changed and the first opinion did not survive. On January 16, 2026, a divided panel issued Sirius Solutions, L.L.L.P. v. Commissioner, 165 F.4th 374 (5th Cir. 2026) (withdrawn), which treated "limited partner" as a partner in a state-law limited partnership who has limited liability. On August 12, 2026, the Fifth Circuit withdrew that opinion and substituted a new one, now captioned K Alain, L.L.L.P. v. Commissioner, No. 24-60240 (5th Cir. Aug. 12, 2026). The replacement opinion holds that a "limited partner" under Section 1402(a)(13) is "a partner who plays no significant role in managing or running a business." The court vacated the Tax Court's decision and remanded for that standard to be applied. The opinion is binding in the Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi).

On September 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed the Tax Court in the Soroban appeal, Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner, Nos. 25-2079 and 25-2250 (2d Cir. Sept. 17, 2026). It defined a limited partner, for purposes of the exception, as a partner who has limited liability and who does not run, manage, or otherwise exert control. Because Soroban's principals exercised managerial control, their distributive shares were subject to self-employment tax.

The First Circuit has not yet spoken. The court heard oral argument in Denham Capital Management LP v. Commissioner, No. 25-1349, on February 5, 2026. The panel spent most of the argument on a threshold procedural question about TEFRA jurisdiction over net earnings from self-employment, so the court may decide the case without reaching the definition of "limited partner." As of this writing, no opinion has issued.

The Ninth Circuit, which includes California, has not ruled. Under the Golsen rule, the Tax Court follows a Court of Appeals decision only in cases appealable to that circuit. For a California taxpayer, the Tax Court's functional test in Soroban is the precedent that court would apply. Active LLC members and limited partners in Los Angeles should assume they owe self-employment tax unless they are genuinely passive and stay out of management. Courts have applied a similar functional approach to active partners in a professional limited liability partnership since Renkemeyer, Campbell & Weaver, LLP v. Commissioner, 136 T.C. 137 (2011). Guaranteed payments for services are included in self-employment income even when the limited partner exception otherwise applies.

A partner who qualifies for the limited partner exception is usually also passive under Section 469. Passive trade or business income is net investment income under Section 1411(c)(2)(A). Section 1411 has its own trade or business exception for nonpassive income, so income that is not from a passive activity, and is not from a trading business, is generally not net investment income. If the taxpayer is already over the net investment income tax threshold, the self-employment tax avoided above the Social Security wage base is about the same 3.8 percent that Section 1411 then imposes. Most of the savings therefore sit in the 12.4 percent Social Security portion below the wage base. The best fact pattern is a partner who works enough hours to be nonpassive under Section 469 but does not run or manage the business. That partner may qualify for the Section 1402(a)(13) exception without turning the income into net investment income.

Planning follows those facts, not the state-law label. One path is an S corporation with defensible reasonable compensation, so that employment tax is paid on wages and the remaining distributive share is generally not self-employment income, subject to the assignment-of-income risks discussed in Fleischer. Another is a limited partnership with a management-company split, in which a separate entity manages the business and the limited partners stay out of management. That structure only helps if the limited partners actually stay out. After Soroban and K Alain, a management-company agreement will not rescue a partner who still runs, manages, or controls the business. A third path is to accept self-employment tax and put the capped Social Security wage base to work through retirement plan contributions, so that the tax paid on the earnings up to the wage base also supports a larger contribution. Earned income for a self-employed plan is net earnings from self-employment (Section 401(c)(2)), so income excluded under Section 1402(a)(13) cannot support Keogh or solo 401(k) contributions. Which path is better depends on the client's role, the entity, and the circuit in which a dispute would be heard.

Five Questions Before You Call a Loss Deductible

Before telling a client that a loss is deductible on this year's return, ask these five questions:

  1. Is it deductible under Section 162, after the provisions that override it?
  2. Is there basis under Section 704(d) or 1366(d)?
  3. Is the client at risk under Section 465?
  4. Is the loss passive under Section 469?
  5. Does it exceed the Section 461(l) threshold?

For business interest, add whether Section 163(j) has limited the deduction after basis and before the later layers. Then, if the client is a partner or LLC member, ask whether self-employment tax applies under Section 1402.

Section 162 tells you whether an expense is deductible. Basis, Section 163(j), Section 465, Section 469, and Section 461(l) tell you when the client gets the benefit. Section 1402 tells you what it costs in self-employment tax.

Key Takeaways

  • Ordinary and necessary is only the first test. Sections 262, 263, 263A, 274, and 280E can still take the deduction back.
  • At the owner level, a loss clears basis, then Section 163(j), then Section 465, then Section 469, then Section 461(l), and any excess becomes a Section 172 net operating loss.
  • Partnership basis often includes a share of liabilities under Section 752. S corporation debt basis generally includes only amounts the shareholder actually loans to the corporation. That gap is where many K-1 errors start.
  • An undisclosed grouping that Revenue Procedure 2010-13 required to be reported is treated as no grouping. Self-rental income is nonpassive; a self-rental loss stays passive. Suspended passive losses often produce their value at exit, under Section 469(g).
  • As of November 2026, limited liability alone is not enough for the Section 1402(a)(13) exception in the Fifth or Second Circuit. The partner also has to stay out of management. In California, the Tax Court's functional test is the rule the Tax Court would apply until the Ninth Circuit speaks.

If you want help reviewing a client's basis, at-risk and passive loss limitations, or self-employment tax position, schedule a consultation with SMB CPA Group, or contact us with your questions.

Disclaimer: The information presented on this website or any SMB CPA Group, PC online platform is for general information and illustrative purposes only. It should not be considered tax, legal, financial, or other professional advice. The content is not intended to provide definitive answers or solutions to specific business situations and is not a substitute for careful research or the advice of a licensed professional that knows your unique circumstances.

Readers are advised not to rely solely on SMB CPA Group materials or use them as the basis for any business, legal, tax, or accounting decision without first seeking independent subject matter expertise and counsel. All case studies shown are hypothetical and intended for demonstration purposes only; results shown are not guarantees of performance or outcomes.

Please contact an SMB CPA Group professional directly to discuss your specific questions or business situation. Our team would be happy to speak with you about a tailored consultation to your needs. We also encourage all readers to seek counsel from licensed attorneys, financial advisors, CPAs, Enrolled Agents, or other qualified professionals prior to making decisions related to their finances or enterprises.

Published By:

Levon Galstian, CPA, AEP®
Managing Principal and CPA

SMB CPA Group

Strategic Tax Advisory.
Insightful Accounting.
Reliable Professionals.

Every engagement begins with a clear understanding of your needs, an honest assessment of mutual fit, and a defined scope of work.